Record No: CB 120750    Version: 1 Council Bill No: CB 120750
Type: Council Bill (CB) Status: Did Not Pass
Current Controlling Legislative Body Land Use Committee
On agenda: 4/30/2024
Ordinance No:
Title: AN ORDINANCE relating to land use and zoning; establishing the Connected Community Development Partnership Bonus Pilot Program; and adding new Sections 23.40.090 through 23.40.097 to the Seattle Municipal Code.
Sponsors: Tammy J. Morales
Supporting documents: 1. Summary and Fiscal Note, 2. Summary Att A - SEPA Threshold Determination of Non-significance, 3. Presentation (3/20/24), 4. Central Staff Memo (3/20/24), 5. Amendment 1, 6. Amendment 2, 7. Amendment 3, 8. Amendment 4, 9. Amendment 5, 10. Divided Report, 11. Proposed Amendment A, 12. Proposed Amendment B

CITY OF SEATTLE

ORDINANCE __________________

COUNCIL BILL __________________

title

AN ORDINANCE relating to land use and zoning; establishing the Connected Community Development Partnership Bonus Pilot Program; and adding new Sections 23.40.090 through 23.40.097 to the Seattle Municipal Code. 

body

BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY OF SEATTLE AS FOLLOWS:

Section 1. The City Council finds and declares:

A. In April 2021 the City published Market Rate Housing Needs and Supply Analysis, which identified that:

1. Approximately 46,000 Seattle households are cost burdened, meaning that those households spend more than half of their incomes on rent;

2. Housing supply is not keeping pace with demand;

3. Housing costs are increasing more quickly than income;

4. Seattle has insufficient zoned capacity for “missing middle” ownership housing;

5. The rental housing market has a shortage of housing affordable and available to lower income households;

6. Approximately 34,000 lower-wage workers commute more than 25 miles to Seattle demonstrating a latent demand for affordable workforce housing; and

7. As Seattle’s share of higher income households grows, development of housing for those households increases economic and physical displacement of lower income residents.

B. With the passage of Chapter 332, Laws of 2023, Seattle must modify current land use regulations to accommodate a range of middle housing types. The City is currently in the process of environmental review for the next major update to the Comprehensive Plan, which must meet the requirements of Chapter 332, Laws of 2023.  To inform future implementation of the Comprehensive Plan update, the City has an interest in exploring development pilots to demonstrate development types and partnerships that leverage community assets to provide equitable development that will not contribute to economic and physical displacement of current residents.

C. Implementing this pilot program is implementing an affordable housing incentive program under RCW 36.70A.540.  The pilot program applies in most zones where residential development is allowed except some highrise zones, historic districts, and industrial areas that allow residential uses.  Additional development capacity is available for development utilizing the pilot program in areas with historical racially restrictive covenants or census tracts identified by the Office of Housing for the community preference policy. Increased residential development in the area where the pilot program applies, in addition to supporting housing affordability, will increase housing choices and support development of housing and amenities, consistent with the Comprehensive Plan.  The pilot program substantially increases residential development capacity for qualifying development in the areas where it applies.  And, the increased residential development capacity provided in the areas where the pilot program applies can be achieved, subject to consideration of other regulatory controls on development.   

D. After a public hearing, the Council has determined that the 80 percent of Area Median Income (AMI) income level for rental housing and 100 percent of AMI income level for owned housing set forth in this ordinance will allow for cross-subsidy for units with deeper affordability and is needed to address local housing market conditions consistent with RCW 36.70A.540(2)(b)(iii).

Section 2. New Sections 23.40.090 through 23.40.097 are added to the Seattle Municipal Code as follows:

23.40.090 Connected Community Development Partnership Bonus Pilot Program - Purpose

Sections 23.40.091 through 23.40.097 establish the requirements for the Connected Community Development Partnership Bonus Pilot Program. The purpose of the program is to demonstrate the social benefits of equitable development including community-serving uses and housing available to a spectrum of household incomes by setting onsite affordability standards and incentives for development of housing and equitable development uses through partnerships between public, private, and community-based organizations.

23.40.091 Definitions for Sections 23.40.090 through 23.40.097

For the purposes of Sections 23.40.090 through 23.40.097:

“Equitable development use” means activities, as determined by rule, where all components and subcomponents of the use provide mitigation against displacement pressure for individuals, households, businesses, or institutions, that comprise a cultural population at risk of displacement. An equitable development use may include, but is not limited to, activities such as gathering space, arts and cultural space, educational programming or classes, direct services, job training, or space for other social or civic purposes. Equitable development uses may also include commercial uses including but not limited to commercial kitchens and food processing, craft work and maker spaces, cafes, galleries, co-working spaces, health clinics, office spaces, and retail sales of food and goods.

“Owner unit incentive development” means a qualifying development using bonus floor area where, as determined by rule, on the date of complete building permit application submittal by a qualifying community development organization: (i) some or all of the development site is owned by a person or family with an annual income not to exceed 120 percent of area median income and who have continually resided in a dwelling unit on the property for the past ten years; and (ii) an executed partnership agreement or other binding contractual agreement with a qualifying community development organization exists affirming the applicant’s obligation to provide a dwelling unit on-site for the current owner at no cost and prohibiting resale or sublet by the owner for at least ten years, except in the event of the owner’s death.

“Qualifying community development organization” means a non-profit organization registered with the Washington Secretary of State or a public development authority created pursuant to RCW 35.21.730, that has as its purpose the creation or preservation of affordable state or federally subsidized housing, social housing, or affordable commercial space, affordable arts space, community gathering spaces, or equitable development uses. A qualifying community development organization can consist of a partnership among one or more qualifying community development organizations, or one or more qualifying community development organizations and a partnering for-profit development entity.

“Qualifying development” means a development located on site in which a qualifying community development organization has a legally established and ongoing property-related interest on the date of complete building permit application submittal. To have a legally established and ongoing property-related interest, a qualifying community development organization shall: own at least 51 percent of the property; own at least ten percent when a partner in an entity provides site control for development; have a controlling and active management role in a corporation or partnership that owns a property, such as a sole managing member of a limited liability company or sole general partner of a limited partnership; or some other beneficial interest, as determined by rule.

“Social housing” means a residential or mixed-use structure with at least 30 percent of the dwelling units affordable to households with incomes no higher than 80 percent of area median income that is developed, publicly owned, and maintained in perpetuity by a public development authority, the charter for which specifies that its purpose is development of social housing and at a range of affordability levels within the Seattle corporate limits. Social housing is intended to promote social cohesion, sustainability, and social equity through an intentional distribution of units to households with a broad mix of sizes and incomes ranging between zero percent and 120 percent of median income.

23.40.092 Enrollment period, eligibility requirements, and owner unit incentive development application requirements

A. The enrollment period for the Connected Community Development Partnership Bonus Pilot Program expires on the earlier of: when applications meeting the requirements of Sections 23.40.090 through 23.40.092 have been submitted for 35 projects; or December 31, 2029.  

B. To qualify for the Connected Community Development Partnership Bonus Pilot Program, development must meet the following eligibility requirements:

1. Be a qualifying development; 

2. Be located in a Neighborhood Residential; Multifamily, except Highrise; Commercial; or Seattle Mixed zone;

3. In commercial zones, have at least 75 percent of gross floor area in residential or equitable development use;

4. Not be located in a designated historic district, unless it is an area with historic exclusionary racial covenants; and

5. Have at least 30 percent of dwelling units and 33 percent of congregate residence sleeping rooms, as applicable, as moderate-income units, except that the duration of the recorded restrictive housing covenants shall be 75 years; or be social housing.

C. Applicants with owner unit incentive development shall provide the following documentation when submitting a permit application:

1. An affidavit or other information in a form acceptable to the Director confirming that the property is owned by a person or family with an annual income not to exceed 120 percent of area median income and who have continually resided in a dwelling unit on the property for the past ten years; and

2. An executed partnership agreement or other binding contractual agreement affirming the applicant’s obligation to provide a dwelling unit on-site for the current owner at no cost and prohibiting resale or sublet by the owner for at least ten years. 

23.40.093 Alternative development standards and exemptions

A. In lieu of otherwise applicable development standards contained in Chapters 23.44, 23.45, 23.47A, and 23.48, a proposed development project that meets the requirements of Section 23.40.092 may elect to meet the alternative development standards, as applicable, of Sections 23.40.094 through 23.40.097. A determination by the Director that development meets the alternative development standards of Section 23.40.094 through 23.40.097 is a Type I decision.

B. Exemptions. Eligible projects are exempt from the requirements of Chapter 23.41, Section 23.54.015, Chapter 23.58A, Chapter 23.58B, and Chapter 23.58C.

23.40.094 Development otherwise subject to the requirements of Chapter 23.44 

A. Development permitted pursuant to Section 23.40.092 may meet the following development standards:

1. Except for apartments, the density limit is one dwelling unit per 1,500 square feet of lot area in NR1, NR2, and NR3 zones and one dwelling unit per 1,200 square feet of lot area in RSL zones.

2. The maximum lot coverage is 50 percent of lot area in NR1, NR2, and NR3 zones and 65 percent in RSL zones.

3. The maximum FAR limit is 1.0 in NR1, NR2, and NR3 zones and 1.25 in RSL zones. The applicable FAR limit applies to the total chargeable floor area of all structures on the lot.

                     B. Owner unit incentive development permitted pursuant to Section 23.40.092 may meet the following development standards:

1. The maximum lot coverage is 60 percent of lot area in NR1, NR2, and NR3 zones and 75 percent in RSL zones.

2. The maximum FAR limit is 1.25 in NR1, NR2, and NR3 zones and 1.5 in RSL zones. The applicable FAR limit applies to the total chargeable floor area of all structures on the lot.

C. Permitted uses. In addition to the uses listed in Section 23.44.006, the following uses are permitted outright on lots meeting the requirements of Section 23.40.092: apartments, cottage housing development, rowhouse development, townhouse development, and equitable development.

D. Yard requirements. No structure shall be closer than 5 feet from any lot line, except that in RSL zones if the rear yard abuts an alley there is no rear yard requirement.

23.40.095 Development otherwise subject to the requirements of Chapter 23.45

A. Floor area

1. Development permitted pursuant to Section 23.40.092 is subject to the FAR limits as shown in Table A for 23.40.095.

Table A for 23.40.095  FAR limits for development permitted pursuant to Section 23.40.092

 

FAR limit

FAR limit in areas with racially restrictive covenants or areas eligible for community preference policy

Maximum additional exempt FAR1

Maximum additional FAR for owner unit incentive development

LR1

1.6

1.7

0.5

0.3

LR2

1.8

1.9

1.0

0.5

LR3 outside urban centers and urban villages

2.5

2.7

1.0

0.5

LR3 inside urban centers and urban villages

3.0

3.3

1.0

0.5

MR

5.6

5.8

1.0

0.5

Footnote to Table A for 23.40.095  1 Gross floor area for uses listed in subsection 23.40.095.A.2 are exempt from FAR calculations up to this amount.  

 

2. In addition to the FAR exemptions in subsection 23.45.510.D, an additional FAR exemption up to the total amount specified in Table A for 23.40.095 is allowed for any combination of the following floor area:

a. Floor area in units with two or more bedrooms and a minimum net unit area of 850 square feet;

b. Floor area in equitable development use; and

c. Any floor area in a development located within 1/4 mile (1,320 feet) of a transit stop or station served by a frequent transit route as determined pursuant to subsection 23.54.015.B.4.

3. Split-zoned lots

a. On lots located in two or more zones, the FAR limit for the entire lot shall be the highest FAR limit of all zones in which the lot is located, provided that:

1) At least 65 percent of the total lot area is in the zone with the highest FAR limit;

2) No portion of the lot is located in an NR1, NR2, or NR3 zone; and

3) A minimum setback of 10 feet applies for any lot line that abuts a lot in an NR1, NR2, or NR3 zone.

b. For the purposes of this subsection 23.40.095.A.3, the calculation of the percentage of a lot or lots located in two or more zones may include lots that abut and are in the same ownership at the time of the permit application.

B. Maximum height

1. Development permitted pursuant to Section 23.40.092 is subject to the height limits as shown in Table B for 23.40.095.

Table B for 23.40.095 Structure height for development permitted pursuant to Section 23.40.092

Zone

Height limit (in feet)

LR1

40

LR2

50

LR3 outside urban centers and urban villages

55

LR3 inside urban centers and urban villages

65

MR

95

2. Split-zoned lots

a. On lots located in two or more zones, the height limit for the entire lot shall be the highest height limit of all zones in which the lot is located, provided that:

1) At least 65 percent of the total lot area is in the zone with the highest height limit;

2) No portion of the lot is located in an NR1, NR2, or NR3; and

3) A minimum setback of 10 feet applies for any lot line that abuts a lot in an NR1, NR2, or NR3 zone.

b. For the purposes of this subsection 23.40.095.B, the calculation of the percentage of a lot or lots located in two or more zones may include lots that abut and are in the same ownership at the time of the permit application.

C. Maximum density. Development permitted pursuant to Section 23.40.092 is not subject to the density limits and family-size unit requirements of Section 23.45.512.

23.40.096 Development otherwise subject to the requirements of Chapter 23.47A

A. Maximum height

1. The applicable height limit for development permitted pursuant to Section 23.40.092 in NC zones and C zones as designated on the Official Land Use Map, Chapter 23.32 is increased as shown in Table A for 23.40.096.

Table A for 23.40.096 Additional height for development permitted pursuant to Section 23.40.092

Mapped height limit (in feet)

Height limit (in feet)

30

55

40

75

55

85

65

95

75

95

85

145

95

145

2. Split-zoned lots

a. On lots located in two or more zones, the height limit for the entire lot shall be the highest height limit of all zones in which the lot is located, provided that:

1) At least 65 percent of the total lot area is in the zone with the highest height limit;

2) No portion of the lot is located in an NR1, NR2, or NR3 zone; and

3) A minimum setback of 10 feet applies for any lot line that abuts a lot in an NR1, NR2, or NR3 zone.

b. For the purposes of this subsection 23.40.096.A.2, the calculation of the percentage of a lot or lots located in two or more zones may include lots that abut and are in the same ownership at the time of the permit application.

B. Floor area

1. Development permitted pursuant to Section 23.40.092 is subject to the FAR limits as shown in Table B for 23.40.096.

Table B for 23.40.096  FAR limits for development permitted pursuant to Section 23.40.092

Mapped height limit (in feet)

FAR limit

FAR limit in Areas with Racially Restrictive Covenants or Areas Eligible for Community Preference Policy

Maximum additional exempt FAR1

Maximum additional FAR for owner unit incentive development

30

3.00

3.25

0.5

0.5

40

3.75

4.00

1.0

0.5

55

4.75

5.00

1.0

0.5

65

4.50

5.75

1.0

0.5

75

5.50

6.00

1.0

0.5

85

7.25

7.50

2.0

0.5

95

7.50

7.75

2.0

0.5

Footnote to Table B for 23.40.096  1 Gross floor area for uses listed in subsection 23.40.096.B.2 are exempt from FAR calculations up to this amount.

2. In addition to the FAR exemptions in subsection 23.47A.013.B, an additional FAR exemption up to the total amount specified in Table B for 23.40.096 is allowed for any combination of the following floor area:

a. Floor area in units with two or more bedrooms and a minimum net unit area of 850 square feet;

b. Floor area in equitable development use; and

c. Any floor area in a development located within 1/4 mile (1,320 feet) of a transit stop or station served by a frequent transit route as determined pursuant to subsection 23.54.015.B.4.

3. Split-zoned lots

a. On lots located in two or more zones, the FAR limit for the entire lot shall be the highest FAR limit of all zones in which the lot is located, provided that:

1) At least 65 percent of the total lot area is in the zone with the highest FAR limit;

2) No portion of the lot is located in an NR1, NR2, or NR3 zone; and

3) A minimum setback of 10 feet applies for any lot line that abuts a lot in an NR1, NR2, or NR3 zone.

b. For the purposes of this subsection 23.40.096.B.3, the calculation of the percentage of a lot or lots located in two or more zones may include lots that abut and are in the same ownership at the time of the permit application.

C. Upper-level setback. An upper-level setback of 8 feet from the lot line is required for any street-facing facade for portions of a structure exceeding the mapped height limit designated on the Official Land Use Map, Chapter 23.32.

23.40.097 Development otherwise subject to the requirements of Chapter 23.48

A. Maximum height. The applicable maximum height limit for residential uses in development permitted pursuant to Section 23.40.092 in Seattle Mixed zones is increased by the following amounts:

1. For zones with a mapped maximum height limit of 85 feet or less, 20 feet.

2. For zones with a mapped maximum height limit greater than 85 feet, 40 feet. 

3. Split-zoned lots

a. On lots located in two or more zones, the height limit for the entire lot shall be the highest height limit of all zones in which the lot is located, provided that:

1) At least 65 percent of the total lot area is in the zone with the highest height limit;

2) No portion of the lot is located in an NR1, NR2, or NR3 zone; and

3) A minimum setback of 10 feet applies for any lot line that abuts a lot in an NR1, NR2, or NR3 zone.

b. For the purposes of this subsection 23.40.097.A, the calculation of the percentage of a lot or lots located in two or more zones may include lots that abut and are in the same ownership at the time of the permit application.

B. Floor area. The applicable maximum FAR limit for residential uses in development permitted pursuant to Section 23.40.092 in Seattle Mixed zones is increased by the following amounts:

1. For zones with a mapped maximum residential height limit of 85 feet or less, 1.0 FAR.

2. For zones with a mapped maximum residential height limit greater than 85 feet, 2.0 FAR. 

3. Split-zoned lots

a. On lots located in two or more zones, the FAR limit for the entire lot shall be the highest FAR limit of all zones in which the lot is located, provided that:

1) At least 65 percent of the total lot area is in the zone with the highest FAR limit;

2) No portion of the lot is located in an NR1, NR2, or NR3 zone; and

3) A minimum setback of 10 feet applies for any lot line that abuts a lot in an NR1, NR2, or NR3 zone.

b. For the purposes of this subsection 23.40.097.B.3, the calculation of the percentage of a lot or lots located in two or more zones may include lots that abut and are in the same ownership at the time of the permit application.

Section 3. The Council requests that by June 30, 2024, the Directors of the Seattle Department of Construction and Inspections, the Office of Housing, and the Office of Planning and Community Development, in consultation with the Equitable Development Initiative Advisory Board, promulgate by Director’s Rule:

A. A process and criteria for verifying that an organization is a qualifying community development organization with a legally established and on-going property-related interest in a site that would make it eligible to apply for development under the pilot program. Provided that, a qualifying community development organization may consist of a partnership between a qualifying community development organization and one or more community development organizations that do not have as their purpose the creation or preservation of affordable state or federally subsidized housing, social housing, or affordable commercial space, affordable arts space, community gathering spaces, or equitable development uses. Partnering community development organizations could include incorporated entities that advocate or provide services for refugees, immigrants, communities-of-color, members of the LGBTQIA communities, members of the community experiencing homelessness, and persons at risk of economic displacement. Partnering community development organizations could also include community-based organizations eligible for the new Jumpstart Acquisition and Preservation Program, which was added to the Housing Funding Policies through Ordinance 126611.

B. A process and criteria for verifying that an application utilizing the owner unit incentive includes an owner and agreement meeting the requirements of this ordinance.  

C. A regulatory definition of “equitable development use” and a process and criteria for ensuring that an equitable development use will continue to occupy leasable space for the life of a development. 

Section 4. By June 30, 2030, the Council, in consultation with the Planning Commission, will evaluate the pilot to assess its effectiveness in achieving the following objectives:

A. Providing affordable workforce housing for communities and households that are cost-burdened;

B. Providing neighborhood-serving equitable development uses;

C. Forestalling or preventing economic and physical displacement of current residents; and

D. Demonstrating a variety of missing middle housing types that are affordable to households with a range of household incomes.

 

Section 5.  Section 2 of this ordinance shall take effect on June 30, 2024.

Section 6. This ordinance shall take effect as provided by Seattle Municipal Code Sections 1.04.020 and 1.04.070.

Passed by the City Council the ________ day of _________________________, 2024, and signed by me in open session in authentication of its passage this _____ day of _________________________, 2024.

____________________________________

President ____________ of the City Council

                     Approved /                     returned unsigned /                     vetoed this _____ day of _________________, 2024.

____________________________________

Bruce A. Harrell, Mayor

Filed by me this ________ day of _________________________, 2024.

____________________________________

Scheereen Dedman, City Clerk

(Seal)

Attachments: